Friday, February 8, 2013


Your Brain Under Fire

Kiyotaka ISHIKAWA

Gunfire in playing Call of Duty is made in simple combination of your lefthand’s adjusting the stick at enemies and your righthand’s squeezing the trigger with a game-controller. Only these processes sometimes fails or delays in your excited hands when you see that your enemies also point their guns at you which looks about to fire. Such a mistake is a part of the mixture of pleasure and stress in the virtual gunfight, but, in the real gunfight, under much more complex and dynamic situations, that might cause you or those who you need to protect killed in a moment. Are armed guards in U.S. schools really more capable of protecting children from active shooters than banishing all firearms from the country? 

Increasing schools guarded by armed security
About a third of all public schools in the United States already have armed security, and that number may increase after the Newtown shootings, as the NRA’s chairman stated, “The only thing that stops a bad guy with a gun is a good guy with a gun.” However, shooting down a bad guy without unintended shots on innocent people requires highly trained skills and minds. Actually, average NYPD hit rate during a gunfight is only 18% when the target is shooting at officers, while it marks 30% when the target dose not fire back (TIME, issued Jan 28, 2013). Moreover, if hiring an officer or armed educator for the case of school assault, we always have to concerns about the high risk that they will shoot a child by accident. 

Possess a gun not only for shooting someone
It is considerable that the presence of armed teachers or guards could deter a shooter from attacking so that there would be no need to perform well in a gunfight. In fact, New York City police officers rarely fire their weapons in the duty, but the silent presence of officers’ weapons surely influences the behavior of citizens around them. Many gun-rights advocates also worry that vulnerability of gun-free schools may attract shooters, pointing out the deterrent function of keeping the armed security.

Need to consider shooter’s uncertain motive for assault
It is difficult to know if mass murderers apply such logic when choosing targets; not all of them simply seek the most violent crime scenes in order to create socially sensational shock. In the case of the 1999 Columbine High School shooting, for example, the attacking students were aware that their school had an armed officer, who eventually failed to stop the mass murder. Also, some studies shows that two thirds of shooters attack their own communities, no matter which they are easy targets or not, just like the case of Columbine. 

From these perspectives, it is unsure that making every U.S. school protected by armed guards or teachers, even if they are well-trained for emergency, could prevent tragedies like the Newtown’s case for ever, though at least that will minimize the number of such cases happen or victims. Of course, nothing is better than banishing all guns, if putting aside huge political and operational costs that will take in the society where gun-rights are deeply rooted. 

Wednesday, January 30, 2013


Polio Coming Back On Politics, Mistrust, and War

Kiyotaka ISHIKAWA

It is very rare that people appreciate being kept from contracting polio for life until they find the disease is still scourge in a few developing countries like Pakistan. Polio is one of the pathological history for rich countries in which humans ended up with a victory in fighting for the eradication and the virus locked down into medical laboratories, but some local health workers, international funds, and Bill Gates are still in battles against polio in the least developing countries; nevertheless far from the eradication. What makes polio’s endless nightmare in those specific regions. 

Polio’s natures that make it difficult to exterminate
First of all, contracting polio does not necessarily result in paralysis, but only one per 200 polio infections does, which means the rest look like having a cold or a passing fever while spreading the virus all the time. Second, the virus moves fast. it took only two years for Nigeria’s infections almost eliminated in 2003 to spread over all the country’s regions and then throughout Asia and down to Oceania. These natures are why the virus must be prevented from the epidemic by patient and exhaustive immunizations. 

Socioeconomic reasons that allow polio alive 
Pakistan, one of last three countries with Afghanistan and Nigeria still fighting against polio, is suffering from slow progress over the public immunization program provided by the government with financial and material supports from WHO and some international development banks. The project has been sabotaged by Pakistani Taliban; directly, they attacked and killed some of polio-vaccine deliverers and medical aid workers who consist of local women and teenage girls; indirectly, they rumored that the polio vaccine contains HIV or sterilize children, most of which are groundless and unscientific but powerful in combination with people’s fear of outsiders and general suspicion of anything touched by the West. What’s more, local religious leaders tend to refuse the vaccination offer for children in their village because of religious dogma or belief in the rumors. 

Intensive funding plus something for immediate eradication
Fighting these periodic outbreaks might be more expensive than finishing up polio immediately with intensive funding on effective programs. Rotary International and other groups calculated spending $1 billion annually over the next few years to extinguish polio would save $50 billion over the next 2 decades both in treatments for infected children and in the perpetual hold-the-line vaccination programs (TIME issued Jan 14, 2013). However, this fund is to effectively distribute only through local efforts, such as appealing to rural religious leaders to encourage the care of children as well as individuals to give a reason why the vaccination is worth trusting and why those rumors of vaccine-related side effects are worthless. Not only these human resources but also technical innovations like GPS trackers on vaccine shipment are necessary to prevent them from missing out due to Taliban attacks. Most of these costs arise from information asymmetries between those who try to help, for example, Bill Gates, and those who want help but hardly appreciate it, for example, extremists, religious leaders, and poorly-educated folks. And this is the very target we have to deal with in order to release people from ever lasting fight against polio. 

Sunday, January 6, 2013


Should We Know It Or Should Not?
-Individual genome testing reveals every disease risk, even if no treatment available-

Kiyotaka ISHIKAWA

What would you do if your baby was revealed the risk of mental disabilities in the distant future; for example, a high probability of Alzheimer’s at his 50s? Parents tends to answer that they want to know every disease risk with their children even if no treatment available while a majority of doctors, researchers, and bioethicists who engage in genetic testing say they should be informed only results which could be immediately treatable. 

Genetic test available for everyone
The mapping of the human genome completed a decade ago costs $2.7 billion, but now an individual’s whole-genome sequencing (WGS) is available from $7,500 and will be provided at a much less cost in the future. A teaspoon of blood is all you need for the test that read every bit of information in your genome and find any mistakes in the basic arrangement of genes that might cause diseases. Moreover, some researchers reported that the pre-born DNA test was successfully operated by analyzing a fetus’ DNA from cells gathered from the mother’s blood.  

The DNA dilemma
Most parents who experienced Parkinson’s disease, a progressive neurologic disease caused by genetical defects, amongst their relatives by blood tend to want the WGS for their children even if no effective treatment has developed (TIME, issued December 24 2012). In addition, the genetic testing might bring about incidental findings which the clients were not looking for. There is a serious argument for doctors to decide how much to tell patients or their parents especially in the case of an incurable adult-onset disease such as Alzheimer’s, concerning about a lifelong burden on the clients and their family; if a mother learnt her girl carries a mutation that increase ovarian cancer, she would feel much responsibility of her own blood. 

Getting along with the results
A common response from doctors is that one possible solution to the problem is to do no harm, which means patients would be better to have only a part of results that could be acted on immediately. A new Web-based venture called My46 offers a online service that store genome sequencing results and chose what people want to know and when. For example, parents can learn any risks of childhood diseases with their baby distinguished from unclear results and increased risks of adult-onset diseases amongst a whole data on his genome. If any adult diseases are expected at a specific stage of his life, he and his family will be warned about them in advance so that they can reduce the risk and prepare for presenting symptoms. 

Sunday, December 23, 2012


Publishing could be popularized?

Kiyotaka ISHIKAWA


The year 2012 might be the first year of self-publishing in the United States while it is called the first year of e-book history in Japan. Before the e-book prevails over the Internet, self-publishing meant a literary coterie magazine (Doujin-shi) or an expensive hobby for scholars and amateur writers, but that will be no longer so. Every writer can publish his or her works only at the cost of manuscripts if they are distributed on the Kindle e-book store which allows anyone to sell their books directly to all Kindle readers over the world. This sounds innovative but little chance to be a million seller; instead, book authors can meet a tiny demand for his story that would be too small to be captured by conventional paper publishing. 

Another Long Tale by Amazon
One reason why Amazon could have successfully introduced self-published e-books by obscure authors is that those books are so cheap compared to those produced by the big publishing house. It costs only 2.99 dollars and distribute 70 per cent of sales for self-published writers; Amazon said such books accounted for 30 of its top 100 sellers in October (TIME, issued December 10, 2012). Self-published titles now exceed 200,000 and still grow at a much higher pace than the printed does. Consequently, adding up all those little sales that the traditional houses missed out, it is estimated self-publishing blessed Amazon about 100 million dollars in revenue last year. 

How so many writers go solo
First, self-publishing before the Kindle was so expensive and a high possibility of no return for the considerable investment. An American amateur writer costed 1,800 dollars for her romance story by hiring a freelance editor and a cover artist, but she sold 20 or so copies, netting about 60 dollars. Second, every writer can get an access to the world largest e-book store that consists of tens of millions of Kindle readers. No concern that your work might be lost amongst the infinite market place full of similar self-publishers. The algorithms behind online book recommendations are so powerful to bring potential readers  based on other reader's book review if your books are worth writing an impression. 

The cost of self-publishing (or the role of publishing houses)
The more famous such self-publishers become and the more revenues they gain from the Kindle store, however, the more publishing affaires they have to devote their time which otherwise would be performed by the publishing houses. Producing yourself as a writer on your own requires various things; cover art, back matters, PR, oversea translation for foreign markets, pricing, and arranging all these matters together. Another problem in self-publishing is that all risk of publishing need to be treated by the writer himself. Once he get a contract from the publishing industry although it is very difficult, the publisher will share his risk of failure. Actually, the nine of the ten fails commercially but those loss could be covered by the only one hit, which is called the rule of thumb. Also, no matter which his works go hit or trash, his editor will prevent him from having legal troubles due to his carelessness against plagiarizing and offensive expressions. These models indicate that self-publishing has just found a niche market between indie writers and lovers and it is nothing like replacing the conventional roles of professional publishers. 

What ‘Big Data’ make difference in political campaigns?

Kiyotaka ISHIKAWA


Tomorrow is the vote day for Japan’s parliamentary election. This is why a couple of advertising vans are coming and going on the every major streets all the time, calling for supports with a speaker loudly. The mass advertisement seems still powerful in political campaigns at least for now that would be the last thing still remaining popularized while most of ads and media has been individualized along a variety of characteristics after an information revolution. However, this might be no longer so.

The information gap in the U.S. presidential election 
It was not only the campaign promise that gave Obama victory in the election, but also the aggressive information strategy which extracted every single tips about voter’s preference from massive personal databases, called ‘Big Data’, and utilized them into persuasive campaigns tailored along each voter’s taste in a various form of appeal. One example goes like this. If George Clooney was statistically proved fascinating amongst West Coast females ages 40 to 49, those women would be the most likely to hand over cash for a chance to have a dinner with Clooney - and Obama. 

The background of the information revolution in the U.S. campaign
A U.S. campaign manager said, ‘Politics was the goal but political instincts might not be the means. (TIME, Issued November 19, 2012).’  It might be surprising for such an exciting presidential election in America, but the poll has been conventionally around 60%, deteriorating over time. A common challenge for American political parties is how to get supports out of populations who shows indifference about politics. The individualized persuasive appeals through Big Data analysis is an efficient way in the country of huge territory and small density of population although it cost much for correcting data and hiring a number of analyzers, but it would be even cheaper than visiting door to door or buying ad for local papers or TVs in every state, not to mention about running advertising cars over the country. 

The common or deferent aspects in Japan’s political campaign
While Japan also suffers from political indifference especially among young-adult generations, approximately 70% on average over whole voters at the last parliamentary election, contrarily Japan still have advantages of mass advertisement due to a high concentration of populations in metropolitan areas and a high market shares of national newspapers and broadcast stations. This is partially why the mass advertising in Japan sounds imprinting rather than persuading, shouting the candidate’s name repeatedly from a mini-van with a large signboard writing its name and picture. 

An expected information revolution in Japan’s political campaign
However, the situation is gradually shifting digital in this country as well as America. This election will be the first one after twitter and other social network services has prevailed over the country, and many candidates have declared their political stances and replied voters for their supports and oppositions. It is said that the Japanese shows less reluctance against anonymous activities on the Internet, so now would be the time for politicians to call for a vote not from windows of a car but from a window of a display. 

Why Do We Have to Learn the Liberal Arts?

Kiyotaka ISHIKAWA


Students and teachers in Kyoto University face a radical reform in the curriculum of general education which has been criticized that the liberal arts are no more than credit makers since the “yutori” education—devoting longer time for moral education and career development at the expense of fundamental subjects such as language and science, prevailed in high school education schemes and more and more university students started to graduate only with disciplines they majored, or some with nothing. 

Enthusiastic and systematic education or independent and voluntary attitude
The university’s response to such a situation is to reorganize the general education system into a more effective and productive scheme in which students can discover clear academic values and manage their own academic or career goals through learning the liberal arts. In other words, the college authorities try to establish a new curriculum and syllabuses with order and purpose. However, as the reform proposal points out, some subjects would be selected out of the curriculum for abolition due to the limit of supervision and that all lecturers would be controlled under subject requirements, which are concerned  to result in the university education with less diversity and academic neutrality. 

For a nice-looking transcript and meta-academic training
Kyoto university students, on the one hand, spend their undergraduate for taking easy subjects, but on the other hand most of students in typical western universities study hard to take better grades for a perfect transcript. An academic history, e.g., grade point average (GPA), is one of the most important element in job hunting amongst western society, so students try to make a parade of the highest grade on their transcripts. Moreover, the liberal arts are good opportunity to sharpen up one’s critical thinking and discussion skills for his or her following career no matter which is proceeding into further study or starting business. Those subjects consist not only of lectures but also of tutorial or discussion terms that provide students with conventional argument topics regarding  politics, cultural diversity, gender discrimination, bioethics, and so on. 

Learning for liberty
The Bible says, ‘The truth shall make you free (John, Chapter 8, Verses 32).’ In a modern interpretation, those who pursue the truth shall be free from political ideologies, mass media, and his own stereotypes. The liberal arts let students find a diversity of viewpoints of the world through discussions with other students and teachers and give them a recognition that their textbooks have no correct answers for most of issues in the society, nor do politicians, mass media, and even scientists sometimes. These learning processes ensure the intellectual liberty in which one would not forced to believe biased information and keep rational in every important stage of their lives, which I think is one of the fundamentals of higher education. For example, lack of this sense in Japan’s society might run this country into a wrong way, remaining stuck in every stage; politics, diplomacy, economy, and energy. After the Tohoku earthquake and the nuclear disaster, such an aspect of this country has been highlighted in the problems regarding some people brainwashed by health risks of radioactive materials who claims the threats of intaking foods from Tohoku even at the absence of scientific evidences.

Sunday, October 21, 2012


Answer to 2012 Social Benefit Cost Analysis: Dam Project

The study
This report studies social preferability of the dam proposal which aims at an extension of crop yields in the dry-farming area by introducing the irrigation system, including a branch with or without concerning an environmental impact, and then investigates a variation of  social influence of the options under certain assumptions which change within a reasonable range. The study is based on basic methods of Benefit Cost Analysis from evaluating each scenario with their Net Present Values to testing sensitivities of the options against considerable fluctuation of crop prices and yields due to market and weather risks. The investigation proceeds in the following order; introducing each option and their expected impacts, identifying and evaluating costs and benefits, calculating net benefits at the present value, sensitivity tests, and conclusions as a final recommendation for decision makers. 

The options and their likely impacts
Option 1 - The Base Case
Under this option without the irrigation scheme, farms will continue conventional dry-land farming, which earns a hundred dollars per hectare annually without any further costs. River downstream from the dam will remain available and provide with fishing and recreation services at a value estimated with the Travel Cost Method. These values are counted as the opportunity costs in the following options of the dam construction. In addition, downstream wetlands which would be damaged if the dam is constructed will be preserved with their associated natural ecosystem.

Option 2 - Dam Construction Without the Environmental Flow for Wetlands
This option allows the irrigation system installed into the participant farms so that the farmers can achieve higher crop yields as a primary purpose of this project although it will cost much not only for the water authority and the farmers but also for the surrounding natural environment and other economic activities. On the other hand, the dam project is expected to have a couple of positive side-effects such as flood protection and fishing and recreation services. These benefits and costs as a whole, in the form of the Net Present Value, applied a few typical discount rates, are to be assessed in comparison with the base case. 

Option 3 - Dam Construction With the Environmental Flow for Wetlands
Finally, the case with the environmental water flow for wetlands is to be examined in order to estimate an minimum required value of their environmental services to implement the dam project. Under this case, less water is available for irrigation and that will cause crop yields decreased and so benefits from irrigated farmlands reduced; also, some costs just like annual water charges for the farmers will be saved as well. Thus, it is necessary to calculate changes in Net Present Values under the discount rates and estimate an annual required value of the wetlands. 

The costs
Costs for Option 2 and 3, the dam construction with-without the environmental flow for wetlands, are classified on Table 1 into primary or secondary columns and priced or unpriced columns. The primary costs basically consist of those for the dam construction and maintenance and fixed and variable expenditures for the farmers to start and manage irrigation farming. The secondary costs come from a wide range of economy of the country from an economic impact on farmers in other regions with poorer cost-competitive farming to a few environmental damages in the surrounding areas like Algal Blooms and salinity effects. 

Labor costs
A treatment of labour costs needs to be paid a special attention because unemployment  exists in the case of the dam proposal. If the unemployed are entitled to gain some unemployment benefits, those payments are considered as transfer payments in the Benefit-Cost Analysis. 

In this case, a half of the labour employed to construct the dam are currently unemployed and will get the wage equal to the unemployment benefit which are assumed to be 25 per cent of the market wage rate as shown in Table 2. The unemployment benefit, a typical example of transfer payments, is excluded in the analysis because money is transferred from the government to the unemployed without any goods or resources being traded in exchange. Therefore, the real cost arises in employing this kind of labor, otherwise the unemployed makes no opportunity cost by remaining jobless. 

Contrarily, the rest half of the employed labor for the dam construction are currently employed in other industries of the country, if assuming no wage inflation in the labor market by implementing the dam proposal, with being paid the same wage as the dam construction. In other words, even if the dam proposal is not taken place, this labor is supposed to cost the same wage in other parts of economy; thus, the cost for the currently employed labor is not counted in this analysis. 

Income tax
Extra income tax on the farmers in the irrigation district would be regarded as a transfer payment for the same reason mentioned in the discussion of labor costs. Unless making any differences in the quantity of inputs or outputs in the market, taxes and subsidies are basically excluded from calculation. 

Table 1:  A classification of costs

Primary
Secondary
Priced
Priced
Unpriced
Capital costs to construct the dam

Annual operation cost
Cost of converting farm land and the associated on-farm capital costs
The crop yield reduction elsewhere in the country
Salinity effects on the surrounding dry-land farmland
Cost of water for operating the irrigation system
Farm variable and overhead costs each year
Additional cost for Algal Blooms

Cost of water for the initial water storage
Annual water charges for the farmers


Costs of labor currently employed and unemployed 
Opportunity costs of earning from dry-land farming



Table 2:  Annual labor cost for the construction of the dam

Wage for labors currently employed
Wage for labors currently unemployed
Annual labor cost
Annual labor cost (real cost)
$2,500,000/yr
$625,000/yr
$3,125,000
$625,000

The benefits
A main benefit from the dam project is extended crop yields in the irrigation district to an annual value of twenty four hundred dollars per irrigated hectare (see Table 4). Moreover, a variety of secondary benefits will appears in upstream or downstream industries from the crop production and also arise as intangible effects in the surrounding environments of the dam (see Table 3). For example, secondary industries located in downstream of the value chain of the extra crop production, such as flour millers and bakers if the crop is grain, will experience a competitive market amongst competing other traders to obtain the extra product; the similar phenomenon will take place in upstream industries, namely between farmers and input suppliers.  

Table 3:  A classification of benefits

Primary
Secondary
Priced
Unpriced
Priced
Unpriced
Earning form the irrigated crop yield
Salvage value of the initial capital investment in the dam
Additional value of the farmer’s extra crop products
Flood protection service of the dam

Salvage value of the initial capital investment in the on-farm irrigation system
Additional value of the processor’s extra products
Fishing, water sports and recreation services of the dam instead of the river


Extra fertilizers sales of input suppliers in the irrigation district
Fish catches for commercial fishers


Extra fuel and chemical sales in the irrigation district


Table 4:  Annual benefits from irrigated farmlands

Yield
Price
Land
Annual benefit per hectare
Annual benefit as a whole
4t/ha/yr
$600/t
50,000ha
$2,400
$120,000,000

Secondary benefits
In a competitive market, there are no secondary benefits (and costs,) so none should be included in calculation. For instance, given an extra amount of wheat available for flour millers, a flour miller will have to include any extra profit from grain processing in his payments for the wheat. Otherwise competing millers will bid higher and obtain the wheat. So the miller will have no true increase in net income. 

The competition in the output market causes processors and retailers of the extra crop product to bid higher for it, by adding four hundred dollars per ton and a hundred dollars per ton respectively, in order to obtain it. In the analysis, added values in price as a result of competition are omitted from calculation of the Net Present Value as two items corresponding to these values in Table 4 are lined with strikethrough. 

Opposite to the former case, additional revenues of input suppliers from extra fertilizers, fuel, and chemical sales (underlined in Table 4) should be considered as substantial benefits because farm variable and overhead costs include expenditures for extra usage of them.

Calculating net benefit
Option 2 - Dam Construction Without the Environmental Flow for Wetlands
In the case of Option 2, the Net Present Value shows negative figures, and the Benefit Cost Ratio is less than one, under any discount rates not less than 7 per cent, which means the total discounted cost exceed the total discounted benefit if the social rate of time preference or the market rate of inflation in the country is at least 7 per cent. Table 5 also indicates that the Internal Rate of Return, defined as the rate at which the sum of all discounted benefits and costs is zero, is equal to 6.03%.

Table 5:  Net Benefit of Option 2 under three different discount rates

Discount rate
5%
6%
7%
NPV
$60,027,520
$1,285,680
-$43,882,142
BCR
1.03
1.00
0.970
IRR

6.03%



Option 3 - Dam Construction With the Environmental Flow for Wetlands
Under Option 3, all NPV figures corresponding to the same discount rates in Option 2 mark considerable amount of loss in the society, as a result of the reduction in benefit exceeding the save in cost from the the decreased irrigated farmland (see Table 6). In order to compensate such loss in the economy, the environmental services of the wetlands are required to have a minimum value per annum under each discount rate. These values are assumed to arise at the start of year 4 after the dam construction is finished and continue until the end of the project.

Table 6:  Net Benefit of Option 3 under three different discount rates

Discount rate
5%
6%
7%
NPV
-$164,467,310
-$188,612,211
-$206,190,255
BCR
0.904
0.875
0.846
 Minimum value of the wetland per annum
$11,095,665
$14,929,930
$18,946,703

The treatment of uncertainty
Price fluctuation
Fluctuation of commodity prices in the world market frequently takes place due to unpredictable market factors, e.g., good harvests in other countries. Assuming that the world market price for the crop faces the change either by 10 per cent more or less every 5 years (the first one occurs in year 8) from the case of Option 2, the Net Present Values show variations from the case without fluctuation, so the Internal Rate of Return slightly shifts  (see Table 7 and 8). Consequently, normal changes in the world commodity prices, a maximum margin of 10 per cent plus or minus, does not seem to affect the dam project significantly. 

Table 7:  Net Benefit under three different discount rates while the price for the irrigated crop decreases by 10 % every 5 years

Discount rate
5%
6%
7%
NPV
$27,837,177
-$25,607,247
-$66,590,832
BCR
1.02
0.984
0.954
IRR

5.49%


Table 8:  Net Benefit under three different discount rates while the price for the irrigated crop increases by 10 % every 5 years

Discount rate
5%
6%
7%
NPV
$92,217,864
$28,178,608
-$21,173,453
BCR
1.05
1.02
0.985
IRR

6.54%


Drought
Another risk that farmers and other relevant subjects of the project are likely to face is drought. Let the analysis suppose that the irrigation district experiences a drought every 10 years (the first one occurs in year 13,) and the whole water flows for irrigation is unavailable in the drought years; the farmers in the district have to temporarily go back to dry-land farming in those years, but any relevant costs to irrigation does not exist. Compared to the result of the case with price fluctuation, effects of the droughts on the project seem considerably influential; the Internal Rate of Return falls more than one per cent (see Table 9).

Table 9:  Net Benefit under three different discount rates while a drought prevent farmers from irrigation every 10 years 

Discount rate
4%
5%
6%
NPV
$41,431,034
-$16,926,545
-$61,301,244
BCR
1.02
0.990
0.961
IRR

4.68%


Conclusions
First, the study demonstrated that Option 2, the dam construction with the environmental flow for wetlands, is beneficial under a certain range of discount rate; however, even if so, returns from the project which the society will gain are not huge as the Benefit Cost Ratio shows under conventional discount rates. 

Second, under Option 3 which preserves the wetlands at an expense of a portion of water for irrigated farming, the value of the wetlands is required to hold at least some million dollars per annum to implement the project, though the exact value depends on the applied discount rate. 

Finally, the dam project does not seem significantly vulnerable to market and weather risks; if some risks against the crop production like price fluctuation and droughts are expected through the project term, it will be feasible to achieve the net social benefit at a positive figure.